Release type: Transcript

Date:

Interview - WA Mornings, ABC Perth

Ministers:

Senator the Hon Dr Jess Walsh
Minister for Early Childhood Education
Minister for Youth

NADIA MITSOPOULOS: I was telling you how the Bayswater Out of School Care Centre will close at the end of the school term because it's not making enough money. And that came just after Insight Early Learning in Joondalup closed suddenly. And then there's another company called Uplift and that's going to close three of its daycare centres in the Wheat Belt. And then you've got the Wongan Cubby House in Wongan Hills, which is asking for donations and sponsorships because it's gotta keep going after it didn't get operational funding for the first time in 16 years. Now, we were told that 152 services have closed in the last two years across Australia and there could be more than 200 at risk of doing the same by July next year. So, we thought it was time to have a chat to Dr Jess Walsh, who's the Federal Minister for Early Childhood Education. 

SENATOR DR JESS WALSH, MINISTER FOR EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION AND MINISTER FOR YOUTH: Good morning, Nadia.

MITSOPOULOS: Should we be alarmed that 152 childcare services have closed across Australia over the last couple of years and more are likely to follow?

WALSH: Well, what we're seeing at the moment, Nadia, is that there are more services this year than there were last year, but we're seeing some closures due to issues of oversupply. So, we're seeing some closures due to there being too many places for the number of families in the community. And at the same time, we're seeing some under supply where there are not enough services for families. So, we want to see a sector that is high quality, that is affordable and that is located where it's needed. And that's why we're investing in a strong and stable workforce. It's why we're building more services in areas where there are not enough. And it's also why we're exploring an Early Education and Care Commission to help governments plan where services are needed now and into the future.

MITSOPOULOS: Because when we look at WA, for instance, we have daycare centres that are closing in regional WA, where there is an under supply.

WALSH: Well, we are working to build more services in areas of under supply in WA, but those closures of services that are really valued by families can be incredibly distressing and incredibly disruptive to children, to families and educators, because, of course, that continuity of care is absolutely essential for children and access to early learning helps families just make their lives work. So, we do want to see a sector that is strong and stable, that's high quality, that's affordable. That's located where it's needed and in those areas of under supply. It's why we're working with the WA government to build five new early learning services in places that need them most.

MITSOPOULOS: Do you know where they'll be?

WALSH: Yes, we've already announced some of them, Nadia. So, in the Wheat Belt in Merredin, we’re expanding a service with a local provider Read Early Learning, building a brand-new service up in Derby to support the Ngunga women there with the first childcare centre that they'll have in that community. We're building two services in the suburbs of Perth as well, at Greenmount Primary School and in Maarakool as well. And we've got one more service that we haven't announced yet that is agreed that we'll announce soon. So, we want to see more quality and not for profit early learning in the places where families need it most in WA.

MITSOPOULOS: Minister, what are the financial pressures? Because I was just last week speaking to the CEO of one that is closing and she said we just A couldn't fill the places and B, we just couldn't make ends meet. I mean, what are the main financial pressures? Is it as simple as just filling those places?

WALSH. So, that provider talking about not being able to fill the places is an issue that we are seeing at the moment and it does go to issues of oversupply of places in some areas where there are just too many places for the number of families that are in that community. And we're seeing some pressures on providers there and at the same time we are seeing some issues of under supply where there's not enough. So, one of the important reforms that we are looking at is an Early Education and Care Commission to help governments work together, Commonwealth and the states and territories, to make sure that we are locating services where they are needed now and into the future. Because overall there are more services this year than there were last year. But it is true that they're not necessarily where families need them most and we are seeing some closures due to oversupply. We want to see a sector that is high quality, that's affordable, but that's located where it's needed because early learning is just so important for children and for families.

MITSOPOULOS: Do you think recent cases of abuse at childcare centres has also knocked the confidence of parents?

WALSH: I think the main issue in the trends that you're talking about there, Nadia, are around issues of oversupply and undersupply. But I do really acknowledge the challenges that families face when they are hearing horrific stories in early childhood education and care. And I would really want to reassure families that the Commonwealth and the state and territory governments, including WA, have come together to pass the biggest package of reforms that we've ever seen in early education and care to make sure that children are safe. And that is exactly what parents should expect that we would do.

MITSOPOULOS: On 102.5 ABC Perth in WA, you're listening to Jess Walsh, the Federal Minister for Early Childhood Education. And just on the funding issue because obviously the Government does provide funding for some childcare centres. We were speaking to Wongan Cubby House in the Wheat Belt didn't get funding after 16 years of getting it. It's got some emergency funding and is now asking for community donations to stay open. Generally speaking, what stops a childcare centre from getting funding, particularly if they've been getting it for a couple of decades?

WALSH: Well, that's an interesting story and I'm sure that that service is really valued by the community. The main source of Commonwealth funding is overwhelmingly the Commonwealth childcare subsidy. That's the big engine of funding into early learning. The fact that that service has had several years of community childcare funding is notable. That funding is designed as a safety net to help services with short term viability issues to help them stay sustainable. It is not intended to be a long-term funding option. In the latest round of that community childcare fund we distributed over $100 million to almost 400 services across the country to help those services stay sustainable. But it is a short-term funding stream with a big engine being Commonwealth childcare subsidy. But I'm pleased to see that they were successful in getting some special circumstances funding.

MITSOPOULOS: Ultimately long term would childcare be better placed as part of the state school system?

WALSH: We like the idea of building more early learning co-located with schools and that is why we are doing that, working with the states and territories to do that. So, we definitely think that there is a role for more school-based early learning. But we also know that there are lots of valued services in local communities as well. We think that there should be a mix of services to support families. You know what we really want most of all is a high-quality system, one that is more affordable for families, one that is located where it's needed. And that Early Education and Care Commission that I talked about that we're working on together with the states and territories is really important in all of this. It is true that the early learning sector has grown in a market dominated way and we want to see --

MITSOPOULOS: As in a for profit way.

WALSH: The majority of services are for profit. But by that I mean that services are locating more where they choose to locate rather than necessarily where they're needed. And that is why we're seeing some oversupply in some places that is causing these closures that can be really disruptive. And it's also why we're seeing some undersupply in some places as well. So, we see a role for a Commission to help bring the Commonwealth and the states and territories together and provide a common basis of information about where we actually need services now and in the future so we can support governments to plan better.

MITSOPOULOS: Because finally, Minister, I guess also with the profit sector in childcare, it is unaffordable for a lot of families.

WALSH. So, early learning can be really affordable for some families. And I also acknowledge that some families struggle with affordability as well. We've made huge investments in making early learning more affordable so that today around a quarter of families pay less than $2 dollars per hour out of pocket costs and that really helps them with more affordable early learning. The childcare subsidy, which is that big engine of funding from the Commonwealth, is heavily means, and it means the more that you earn, the less subsidy that you get. So, for low income families, we're seeing $2 dollars an hour out-of-pocket costs, which is really helping families with affordability.